Prometheus
is not Alien. It seems necessary to make this clear. In fact,
thematically it bears more relation to Ridley Scott's own Blade
Runner. Both films ask what it means to be human. Blade Runner asks
these questions indirectly, and even comes close to giving answers;
Prometheus goes straight ahead and asks the questions, then never
fully answers them. In this case, they are raised by a team of
scientists travelling to a distant planet to find the beings
responsible for life on Earth. The name of their ship is Prometheus,
and the implications are clear: you don't mess with the gods. Whether
or not you like the film will probably depend on how much you care
about it's lack of satisfying answers.
Speaking
for myself, I have no problem with remaining mystified. Too many films are
lacking a sense of awe and mystery, and in several key scenes Prometheus delivers just this. The breathtaking design of the film alone is worth the price
of admission; it has to be the most visually beautiful film I've seen
all year. The problem lies with it's failure to succeed on a human level. The embarrassingly weak script and a disjointed story struggle against a strong cast who have to work hard to keep us interested.
Noomi Rapace is a strong leading presence in her first English speaking lead role, with
Scott opting for more than a simple
Ripley re-tread. Her unshaken religious faith, even in the face of
possible answers to life's great questions, is surprisingly original
and refreshing. She's helped by a solid supporting cast, but even
their combined strengths are overshadowed by the presence of Michael
Fassbender. His performance as David, the ship's android, has been
receiving so much acclaim that praising him has almost become a
cliché. It's justified however, and in many ways David is the
central crux of the movie, providing the same function as Rutger
Hauer's Roy Batty in Blade Runner. They both share an Aryan
flawlessness that manifests as veiled contempt of the humans around
them, as well as a vague yearning to be as 'human' as them. There is
a nice touch as David is seen modelling his appearance and speech
pattern on Peter O'Toole in Lawrence of Arabia. Later he offers a
quote from that film to hint at the futility of the mission: “There
is nothing in the desert, and no man needs nothing”.
Ultimately,
Prometheus doesn't hold together. It's fails to come as close as
Blade Runner to answering any of it's central questions, and to
describe the plot and script as messy would be far too kind. It is so staggeringly ambitious that it's
failure to succeed is almost inevitable. It never works as a whole, but there are several moments when it soars.
No comments:
Post a Comment